Skip to content
FuelStackr

Thorne vs Klean Athlete Creatine: Two NSF-Certified Picks Compared

Nathan5 min read
Clear scoop resting in white creatine powder

This post contains affiliate links. If you buy through them, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Read our affiliate disclosure

On this page
  1. Quick Comparison
  2. What They Have in Common
  3. Where They Differ
  4. Price per serving
  5. Tub size
  6. Micronized
  7. Where to buy
  8. Directions
  9. Thorne Creatine
  10. Klean Athlete Klean Creatine
  11. Which Should You Choose?
  12. How to Take Either One
  13. FAQ
  14. Is Thorne or Klean Athlete creatine better?
  15. Are Thorne and Klean Athlete creatine safe for drug-tested athletes?
  16. Does micronized creatine work better?
  17. Do Thorne or Klean Athlete creatine contain Creapure?
  18. Is either one good for women?
  19. The Bottom Line

Thorne and Klean Athlete creatine are nearly identical where it counts: both are plain creatine monohydrate, 5 g per scoop, with no other ingredients, and both are NSF Certified for Sport. Either is an excellent choice. Thorne is the better pick for most people because it costs less per serving and comes in a bigger tub. Klean Athlete makes sense if you already use the brand or find it cheaper at a retailer.

Quick Comparison

Thorne CreatineKlean Athlete Klean Creatine
Creatine per scoop5 g creatine monohydrate5 g creatine monohydrate
Other ingredientsNoneNone
FormMicronized monohydrateMonohydrate
FlavorUnflavoredUnflavored
Servings per tub90 (also 180)About 60
Third-party certificationNSF Certified for SportNSF Certified for Sport
Brand-site price$44 for 90 servings (about $0.49 a serving)$34.50 for about 60 servings (about $0.58 a serving)
LabeledGluten-free, dairy-free, soy-freeGluten-free, GMO-free, vegan

Prices are from each brand's own website, checked November 18, 2026. Klean Athlete lists its price publicly but asks you to log in to buy direct. Prices at other retailers vary.

How we compared: we didn't lab-test these products. We compared each brand's Supplement Facts panel, product details and price, and confirmed both are listed in NSF's Certified for Sport directory.

What They Have in Common

The two products are more alike than different:

  • The same dose of the same ingredient. Each scoop is 5 g of creatine monohydrate, the form behind almost all creatine research, and the standard daily dose.
  • Nothing else added. No flavors, sweeteners, fillers or "proprietary blends." You get creatine and nothing else.
  • NSF Certified for Sport. This is one of the strictest certifications for supplements. NSF tests products to confirm what's on the label is in the tub, and screens for hundreds of substances banned in sport. That matters if you're a tested athlete, and it's a good sign of quality for everyone else.

Third-party testing matters because not every creatine contains what its label says. Some products sold online, especially gummies, have been found to contain much less creatine than they claim. See do creatine gummies work? for more on that.

Where They Differ

Price per serving

On each brand's own site, Thorne works out to about $0.49 a serving and Klean Athlete to about $0.58. Thorne also sells a 180-serving size. Both are mid-priced for creatine; basic unbranded creatine is cheaper, but usually without NSF certification. Prices change often, so compare per-serving cost wherever you buy.

Tub size

Thorne's standard tub has 90 servings, enough for three months at 5 g a day. Klean Athlete's 11.1 oz tub has about 60 servings, or roughly two months.

Micronized

Thorne describes its creatine as micronized, meaning the particles are ground finer so it mixes into water more easily. Klean Athlete doesn't say whether its creatine is micronized. Micronizing doesn't make creatine work better; it just affects how smoothly it dissolves.

Where to buy

Thorne sells direct on its website and at major retailers, including Amazon. Klean Athlete's website asks you to log in before you can add products to your cart, but it's also available at retailers, including Amazon.

Directions

Both say to mix one scoop with about 8 oz of water or another drink. Klean Athlete suggests taking it with a carbohydrate-containing drink or food, before or after training, and with a meal on rest days. In practice, when you take creatine matters much less than taking it every day.

Thorne Creatine

Thorne Creatine is unflavored, micronized creatine monohydrate with 5 g per scoop and 90 servings per tub. It's NSF Certified for Sport and labeled gluten-, dairy- and soy-free. It's also easy to find, both on Thorne's site and at major retailers.

Best for: most people who want a tested, single-ingredient creatine at a fair price.

Thorne Creatine

You can also buy it direct from Thorne.

Klean Athlete Klean Creatine

Klean Creatine is unflavored creatine monohydrate with 5 g per scoop and about 60 servings per tub. It's NSF Certified for Sport and labeled gluten-free, GMO-free and vegan. Klean Athlete is a sports-focused brand whose whole lineup is built around NSF certification.

Best for: people who already use other Klean Athlete products, or anyone who finds it at a better price.

Klean Athlete Klean Creatine

You can also see it on Klean Athlete's website.

Which Should You Choose?

If you…Choose
Want the lowest cost per servingThorne
Want a bigger tubThorne
Want creatine that mixes as smoothly as possibleThorne (micronized)
Already use other Klean Athlete productsKlean Athlete
Find Klean Athlete for less where you shopKlean Athlete
Are a tested athleteEither; both are NSF Certified for Sport

How to Take Either One

  • Take 3–5 g a day, every day, including rest days. One scoop of either gives you 5 g.
  • You don't need to load. A loading phase gets your muscles saturated faster, but a daily dose gets there in about 3–4 weeks. See our creatine dosage guide.
  • Mix it with anything. Both are unflavored, so they work in water, juice, coffee or a protein shake.

FAQ

Is Thorne or Klean Athlete creatine better?

They're essentially the same product: 5 g of pure creatine monohydrate, NSF Certified for Sport. Thorne is cheaper per serving on the brands' own sites and comes in a bigger tub, so it's the better value for most people.

Are Thorne and Klean Athlete creatine safe for drug-tested athletes?

Both are NSF Certified for Sport, which screens for substances banned in sport, so they're about as safe a choice as supplements get for tested athletes. Always check your own sport's rules.

Does micronized creatine work better?

No. Micronized creatine has finer particles, so it dissolves more easily, but it's absorbed and works the same as regular creatine monohydrate.

Do Thorne or Klean Athlete creatine contain Creapure?

Neither brand mentions Creapure on its product page. Creapure is a branded German creatine monohydrate. It's a good sign of quality, but third-party certification like NSF is a more useful check of what's actually in the tub.

Is either one good for women?

Yes. Creatine works the same way for women, at the same dose. Our guide to creatine for women covers the benefits and myths.

The Bottom Line

Thorne and Klean Athlete both make clean, NSF Certified for Sport creatine monohydrate with 5 g per scoop and nothing else. You can't go wrong with either. Thorne edges ahead on value and tub size, so it's our pick for most people. Choose Klean Athlete if you already use the brand, or if you find it for less. For more options, see our ranking of the cleanest creatines.

Products in this article

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

Not medical advice. This article is for information only. Talk to a qualified healthcare professional before starting any new supplement, especially if you have a health condition or take medication.

Written by

Nathan

Founder of FuelStackr. Nathan breaks down supplement labels, compares products, and tests what he recommends across four training sessions a week with a pro trainer.

Start Building a Better Supplement Stack

New guides and reviews in your inbox, once a week.